Evaluating genetic and environmental bottlenecks in planted and naturally colonised woodlands

Project leads  Dr. James Borrell I Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew; Dr. Nadia Barsoum I Forest Research
Collaborators  Woodland Trust
Project status  Complete (April 2022 – March 2025)
Project funding  £496,000
Research outcome  Adaptation
Oak seedlings growing on woodland floor with dappled sunlight on the leaves
Context
The UK has committed to establishing 30,000 hectares of new woodland annually by 2050 and this will be met both by tree planting and natural regeneration. We know that genetic diversity underpins the resilience and future adaptive potential of our tree populations, and that maintaining this diversity is a key goal of the UK Forest Genetic Resources Strategy.

However, as we move towards ambitious afforestation goals, there is a major knowledge gap around the resulting genetic diversity in planted versus naturally colonised woodlands and how this will influence resilience to environmental change, pests, and diseases.

Research aims and objectives
Aim

By working closely with industry stakeholders, who contribute substantially to current afforestation activity we will contribute to development of best practice, aiming to deliver resilient woodland expansion in the UK.

Objectives

This project will assess the differences in genetic diversity in planted versus naturally colonised woodlands, and particularly where climatic, ecological or management drivers result in genetic bottlenecks to young tree populations. It will:

  • Compare the tree health and genetic diversity in planted and naturally colonised young woodlands, focusing on oak (Quercus) and birch (Betula).
  • Characterise potential genetic bottlenecks and selection in planted and natural afforestation pipelines.
  • Draw up actionable recommendations for optimising afforestation activities to help deliver genetically diverse and resilient tree populations.
Expected outcomes
  • The project will provide recommendations on best practice improvements to current tree planting and natural colonisation protocols, including any recommendations to improve current seed sourcing guidelines, record-keeping and propagation.
  • The project will also provide a peer review publication and popular press outputs to communicate findings to a range of audiences.
Further resources linked to this project
Oak seedling in a new plantation, protected by a tree guard
Glossary & Key Terms
Afforestation
The process of establishing a forest in an area where there was no previous tree cover/forest before (or not for a long time).
Birch (Betula)
Birch trees are a genus (Betula) of deciduous hardwood trees known for their distinctive white or silvery bark and graceful form. They are characterised by their thin leaves, often triangular in shape, and are typically found in temperate and boreal regions of the Northern Hemisphere. Birch trees are also known for their use in various applications, including as a source of firewood, in furniture making, and in traditional medicine. The two most common native Birch species in the UK are silver birch (Betula pendula) and downy birch (Betula pubescens). For more information, see Birch Trees – Forest Research.
Genetic bottleneck

A sharp reduction in genetic variation caused by a significant decrease in the number of reproducing individuals. In the context of afforestation, collecting seeds from a limited number of parental trees within a larger population can lead to genetic bottlenecks.

Genetic diversity

Variation in genetic traits within a species or population.

Oak (Quercus)
Oak trees are a group of trees and shrubs belonging to the genus Quercus within the beech family. They are known for their distinctive lobed leaves, hard wood, and characteristic acorns. There are around 500 different species of oak, found in the Northern Hemisphere, and they can be either deciduous or evergreen.

There are two native oak species in the UK: pedunculate oak (Quercus robur) and sessile oak (Quercus petraea), and three non-native species: turkey oak (Quercus cerris), holm oak (Quercus ilex), cork oak (Quercus suber).  For more information, see Oak Trees – Forest Research.

Click below to watch a short talk on this project:

In this talk, Dr Guillermo Friis (Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew) and Nicola Cotterill (Forest Research) present research comparing genetic bottlenecks in planted and naturally colonised woodland on nearby sites and assessing tree health in the different types of woodland creation. 

This talk was part of the ‘Planting, Natural Colonisation, and Adaptation: Oak and Birch’ webinar originally broadcast by the Centre for Forest Protection on 24 March 2025.

Our Partners

© 2022 Centre for Forest Protection. All rights reserved.